Automatic threshold: 500
Fantasy All-Stars
Hall of Fame
The greatest careers in Fantasy All-Stars history, ranked automatically by championships, sustained success, league honors, management achievements, and longevity.
Current GOAT
IAmMooDeng
Rank #1 · 2 Championships
Hall Score421.7/ 750
GOAT Meter100%
Hall Score 400–499
Hall Score 300–399
All-time participants
Immortals
Hall of Fame
No automatic inductees yet
A manager enters the Fantasy All-Stars Hall of Fame automatically when their Hall Score reaches 500.
Next In
Hall of Fame Watch
All-Time
Hall Rankings
#ManagerHall ScoreGOATTitlesWin %AwardsTier
1IAmMooDeng
Jimbaliah
MattWitt
casman02
jtsarnak
JimBob619
matvio16
nherms42
QDubs10
ScubaSteve219
marenella
VanillaG0ri11aawhansenCareer Résumés
Score Breakdown
Rank #1IAmMooDeng50-86 · 2 titles
Hall Score421.7Hall of Fame Watch
Championships200.0 / 250
2 titles · 0 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success75.7 / 200
50 career wins · 2 playoff appearances
Honors78.0 / 150
5 awards · 1 Manager of the Year
Management18.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 1 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter100.0%
Rank #2Jimbaliah77-59 · 1 titles
Hall Score392.0League Legend
Championships115.0 / 250
1 titles · 0 runner-ups · 1 third-place finishes
Success124.0 / 200
77 career wins · 4 playoff appearances
Honors78.0 / 150
5 awards · 1 Manager of the Year
Management25.0 / 100
1 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter92.9%
Rank #3MattWitt99-37 · 0 titles
Hall Score367.2League Legend
Championships80.0 / 250
0 titles · 2 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success158.2 / 200
99 career wins · 5 playoff appearances
Honors54.0 / 150
3 awards · 1 Manager of the Year
Management25.0 / 100
1 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter87.1%
Rank #4casman0292-44 · 1 titles
Hall Score366.9League Legend
Championships155.0 / 250
1 titles · 1 runner-ups · 1 third-place finishes
Success141.9 / 200
92 career wins · 4 playoff appearances
Honors12.0 / 150
1 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management8.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 1 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter87.0%
Rank #5jtsarnak70-66 · 1 titles
Hall Score322.6League Legend
Championships115.0 / 250
1 titles · 0 runner-ups · 1 third-place finishes
Success115.6 / 200
70 career wins · 4 playoff appearances
Honors24.0 / 150
2 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management18.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter76.5%
Rank #6JimBob61981-55 · 0 titles
Hall Score293.7Franchise Great
Championships40.0 / 250
0 titles · 1 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success120.7 / 200
81 career wins · 3 playoff appearances
Honors60.0 / 150
5 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management23.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter69.7%
Rank #7matvio1664-72 · 0 titles
Hall Score263.4Franchise Great
Championships55.0 / 250
0 titles · 1 runner-ups · 1 third-place finishes
Success92.4 / 200
64 career wins · 2 playoff appearances
Honors48.0 / 150
4 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management18.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 1 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter62.5%
Rank #8nherms4275-61 · 0 titles
Hall Score231.6Franchise Great
Championships0.0 / 250
0 titles · 0 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success113.6 / 200
75 career wins · 3 playoff appearances
Honors48.0 / 150
4 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management20.0 / 100
1 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter54.9%
Rank #9QDubs1061-75 · 0 titles
Hall Score185.9Building Legacy
Championships15.0 / 250
0 titles · 0 runner-ups · 1 third-place finishes
Success96.9 / 200
61 career wins · 3 playoff appearances
Honors24.0 / 150
2 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management0.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter44.1%
Rank #10ScubaSteve21949-87 · 0 titles
Hall Score168.5Building Legacy
Championships0.0 / 250
0 titles · 0 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success74.5 / 200
49 career wins · 2 playoff appearances
Honors36.0 / 150
3 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management8.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter40.0%
Rank #11marenella56-80 · 0 titles
Hall Score144.9Building Legacy
Championships0.0 / 250
0 titles · 0 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success82.9 / 200
56 career wins · 2 playoff appearances
Honors12.0 / 150
1 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management0.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter34.4%
Rank #12VanillaG0ri11a42-94 · 0 titles
Hall Score116.2Building Legacy
Championships0.0 / 250
0 titles · 0 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success66.2 / 200
42 career wins · 2 playoff appearances
Honors0.0 / 150
0 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management0.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity50.0 / 50
6 seasons · Charter Member
GOAT Meter27.5%
Rank #13awhansen0-0 · 0 titles
Hall Score0.0Building Legacy
Championships0.0 / 250
0 titles · 0 runner-ups · 0 third-place finishes
Success0.0 / 200
0 career wins · 0 playoff appearances
Honors0.0 / 150
0 awards · 0 Manager of the Year
Management0.0 / 100
0 Best Rookie Draft · 0 Fleece of the Year
Longevity0.0 / 50
0 seasons
GOAT Meter0.0%
Methodology
How Hall Score Works
250Championships
200Success
150Honors
100Management
50Longevity
Hall of Fame membership is entirely algorithmic. Every manager is evaluated using the same 750-point model, and induction occurs automatically at a Hall Score of 500 or higher.
Honors and Management scores use the available archived award evidence from 2023–2025. Awards for 2021–2022 are not archived, so those seasons remain unknown rather than documented zeroes.